Saturday, February 3, 2018

I, Tonya: A Review

I, Tonya is for the most part a good movie. Margot Robbie does a fabulous job as Tonya Harding. Allison Janney is equally impressive as her mother. The other supporting actors, such as Sebastian Stan as Jeff Gillooly and Bobby Cannavale playing a fictional character from Hard Copy are very good.

The film is directed by Craig Gillespie and screenplay written by Steven Rogers. It is critical of Tonya's white trash up bringing, but Tonya did grow up in a hard scrabble abusive Oregon working class family. It is what it is.

The movie goes beyond the banality of evil of the various players in this media melodrama and points the finger at us all who consume these stories. There is a lot of breaking of the fourth wall and it is told in a Rashomon style from the various characters' individual perspectives (which as you can expect widely differ). While the movie at times abruptly shifts tone and it could have been done better, I can forgive that. Sometimes the skating CGI was off, but then again--skating (while important to the story) is not the central focus of the film. Overall, I thought the film worked.  

Paul Walter Hauser as Shawn Eckardt

Shawn Eckardt is depicted in the film as the bungling loser 'mastermind' of the Nancy Kerrigan attack. Paul Walter Hauser does a good job playing him. In a scene in Eckardt's parent's basement (where he lived), there is an old Ronald Reagan poster on the wood paneling that the camera pauses on. The message is obvious--that it was idiots like Shawn (and his family) that gave us Ronald Reagan (and hint hint, Donald Trump).  It was not necessary for the film--it's distracting (although I am sure it will play well for some Academy voters and those rabid anti Trumpers). Would this movie do the same if there was a Carter or Clinton poster in that home? 

The Two Tonyas Together

Julianne Nicholson as Tonya's skating coach

Rotten Tomatoes: I, Tonya

Caitlyn Carver plays Nancy Kerrigan

Rule 5 and FMJRA

Goodstuff's: 225th Edition

Wombat: Ursula LeGuin, RIP

Lem's Place: Trump's SOTU 2018

Hogewash: It's written in the stars?

American Power: Trump's challenge

Woodsterman: How To Age Gracefully

Diogenes' Middle Finger: Opinions, no tips!

90 Miles From Tyranny: Rosie Ground Hog Day!

The Feral Irishman: Tueseyes and Wirecutter, Hitting Bigtime!

Legal Insurrection: Post Polling In: Trump's SOTU speech homerun!

AoSHQ: State of the Union Threads OneTwoThreeFourPost Drinking

Don Surber: Trump changed politics again and Americans Are Dreamers Too

Powerline: Notes and Quotes and A Tremendous Performance by President Trump

DaTechGuy: Making the SOTU great again and Trump's SOTU speech a game changer in 2018

Hot Air: And CNN, I see what you did there and Advice to young ladies in this very stupid era...

AoSHQ/J.J. Sefton: Americans Are Dreamers Too and The Dems leadership hate us, they really do!

Political Clown Parade: Release the MemoSore, you mean wipe it on like Ben-Gay?The Fog of War and The Schumer Shutdown

Animal Magnetism: Hump Day NewsGingermageddonRoad TripSaturdayFridayInvoluntary Servitude News, also, Hump Day News

A View From The Beach: Last NightMcCabe slow rolled the Clinton investigationLove Bird ChatterFinn IndependenceHalloween Costume Scabs

Rush Limbaugh: Who's the narcissist?Maybe the best SOTU speech I have ever seenDemocrats refused to cheerA Speech Only An Outsider Could Give

TOM: 75% ApprovalIllegals at the SOTULaura Dunn, Evil LiarA Seattle Lesbian is suddenly woke!Defamation by Impersonation and Stay Classy, Deb Frisch!

Instapundit: Five Things Democrats Refused To ApplaudBad Night for the DemocratsHot Air: Trememdous SOTULinguistic Kill ShotDemocrats against God and CountryAmericans Are Dreamers TooKnob Creek!

Proof Positive: Best of the WebBrie LarsonDiana MumbySore, you mean wipe it with Ben-Gay?The Best of the WebGoldie HawnBest of the WebFNB Darby StanchfieldVintage Babe of the Week Joan Vohs and Best of the Web

Pirate's Cove: Leave it to the NYT to go barking moonbat over the SOTUSorta blogless pinupOnly in AustraliaSorta blogless pinupWe're saved!Sorta Blogless Pinup and If all you can see is this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or this, or moo!

EBL: Sabo strikes in advance of Academy AwardsLoving VincentGet Out: A ReviewDarkest Hour: A ReviewDunkirk: A ReviewIs H.R. McMaster going to get fired?Jennifer Lawrence goes to whore schoolShape of Water Rule 5Harvey Weinstein expelled from the AcademyBlack Panther: A ReviewAltered CarbonWho did they cast as Dr. Smith in the Lost In Space Reboot?De Blasio Groundhog Day (an un-punished murder), Debra Harry SOTUThe Westeros Unsafety DanceVintage MermaidsElsa PatakySabo Strikes Again: Grammys 2018Nicole EggertHow Hillary deals with sexual harassment,  Jamiel Shaw Murdered By A DreamerWhat President Trump Should Do At The SOTUErick Erickson says we are all cucks nowShutdown Schumer and the Dems react predictably to Trump's DACA dealGOP: You won a battle, now go win the war...Schumer Shutdown Day 3 (and Schumer capitulates), Trump already has a 'wall' that Democrats fearBut what about the Dreamers?Schumer Shutdown Day 2Schumer and the Dems shut down the government

A collection of sites known for appreciation of Rule 5 and crime period movies:

Dust bury
Theo Spark
Daily Gator
Pirate's Cove
Proof Positive
The Right Way
MissK's World...
American Power
Guns and Bikinis
Raconteur Report
Angrymikes hood
The Last Tradition
Adrienne's Corner
The Feral Irishman
Camp of the Saints
Animal Magnatism
Maggie's Notebook
The Classic Liberal
The Rio Norte Line
Randy's Roundtable
A Nod To The Gods
Political Clown Parade
24 Femmes Per Second
The Vulgar Curmudgeon
A View From The Beach
Diogenes' Middle Finger
Your Crazy Uncle Bubba
Old Retired Petty Officer
Ninety Miles From Tyranny
Knuckledraggin My Life Away
In a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World

1 comment:

  1. So here's the one question in my mind when I first heard about "I, Tonya". It's a quote from RedLetterMedia about another film: "But was it a story that needed to be told?"


I had to stop Anonymous comments due to spam. But I welcome all legitimate comments. Thanks.